Peanut Butter & Co.‘s Crunch Time is the best peanut butter I’ve ever had. I graduated from my beloved Jif about a year ago, and when I taste it now I find it sickeningly sweet. Most natural peanut butters, however, taste like wet dirt, or they are overly salty. PB&C’s is wet but manageable, with just the right amount of salt, and no sugar added or needed. Cream Nut can win all the awards it wants, but this is the real deal. Oh, and FreshDirect just began carrying it, presumably at my suggestion. (If you buy this product, I recommend turning it on its head a day before you open it to redistribute the oil.)